Dilemma Birchbox VS Glossybox February

I'm in the middle of a very serious dilemma! I made the decision that I needed to cancel either my Birchbox or Glossybox subscriptions this month as I really need to start saving some money and can't justify paying for both each month. Problem is which one?  I decided to wait until I got this month's boxes to make my decision, unfortunately both boxes this month are great which didn't help me at all. So I thought it would be a good idea to share with you what I got in my boxes this month and ask you what you think?


Let's start with the Birchbox as I received it first.

The products included are

Beauty Protector Protect & Oil

Eyeko Skinny Liquid Eyeliner

Urbanveda  Purifying Daily Facial Wash

Gilchrist & Soames The London Collection Shower Gel

Leighton Denny Nail Colour

Green & Black's Dark 70% Chocolate

I am so excited with this box. I have wanted to try Leighton Denny and Eyeko products for a long time and never gotten round to it. I have never heard of the Beauty Protector oil or the Gilchrist & Soames shower gel but am excited to give them a go. I have tried an Urbanveda product before and loved it but not this particular one so it's nice to try something else in their range. As for the Green and Black's ..... well you can never go wrong with a bit of chocolate :)

Now for the Glossybox

The products are

Ciaté London Paint Pot

NV Chunky Lip Crayon

Giovanni Eco Chic Cosmetics Chic Ultra-Moist Range or Ultra-Sleek Range

Nougat London Sparkling Body Shimmer

Maybelline New York Big Eyes Mascara

Lindt Lindor Treat Bar

Initially the thing I was most excited about was the chocolate bar as I love the Lindt Chocolate! Yum Yum! Then I thought I better look at the beauty items. The item that jumped out as I knew we were receiving this is the Ciaté Paint Pot. I am excited to try this brand. In fact I did do a little test when I got it. It goes on so smoothly and the colour is amazing. It dries really quick, and basically is a pleasure to use. Then I spotted the Maybelline Mascara, I'm sure I have seen someone talk about this recently and thought it looked interesting so I can't wait to try it. The rest of the products are by brands I have never heard of but am equally excited to try! I have to say as well the box is beautiful! I love when Glossybox do their special edition boxes and this one is fab! 

So can you see my problem? So happy with both boxes this month. Do I be naughty and keep both subscriptions? Cancel one? Or cancel both? I don't know what to do. I really need to save some money towards the wedding and doing up my house so I really can't justify continuing both my subscriptions :( What do you think I should do??

jxx